Can we link foot strike patterns to injuries in runners?
Unless your running with an accentuated heel strike with an out-stretched leg well in front of your center of gravity then I say no. Why? Because there are way too many variables involved with running that could lead to injury. Mainly intensity and distance. As Mark Cucuzzella, MD likes to say “running injuries are caused by running”. The injuries they are supposedly linking to, are indirectly related to the foot strike pattern. Meaning if you change your foot strike pattern you need to transition slowly or you will increase injury. Not because you’re barefoot or in a minimalist shoe, but because you “changed” your style of running and your body needs to adapt. See what Amby Burfoot has to say.
Two new studies link footstrike to different injuries.
By Amby Burfoot
Published February 18, 2014
While sales of minimalist shoes have dropped sharply, scientific interest in barefoot running and minimalist shoes remains high. In particular, everyone would like to answer one simple, but very complex question: Can barefoot running or minimalist shoes or forefoot striking reduce injuries?
Two new studies by widely acknowledged shoe experts reach the same conclusion: We don’t know yet, and we may never know, due to the many variables involved.
At the same time, both point to the possibility that different footstrike patterns might cause or prevent specific injuries. This leads to the intriguing possibility that runners could decrease problems with their known injuries by adopting one style of running over another.
The study from Joe Hamill’s well-known UMass biomechanics lab concludes: “There is a possible difference in the types of injuries that may be sustained between the forefoot and rearfoot footfall patterns.”
South African running experts Tim Noakes and Ross Tucker go even farther. In their paper they enumerate five common running injuries, and speculate about how barefoot running (or forefoot striking) might affect each. Note that many researchers use “barefoot running” and “running with a midfoot/forefoot strike” as virtual synonyms, even though some studies have shown differences between the two.
Here’s a summary of the paper’s main points regarding the five common injuries:
1. Tibial stress fracture: Possibly decreased by barefoot running, but be extra careful about your transition time from cushioned shoes.
2. Metatarsal stress fracture: Possibly increased by barefoot running.
3. Knee pain: Possibly decreased by barefoot running.
4. Achilles tendon injuries: Possibly increased by barefoot running
5. Plantar fasciitis: Possibly decreased by barefoot running, but only after a gradual and successful transition from cushioned shoes.
All credible researchers in the field agree that bad training practices – ie, too much, too soon, too fast – are the major cause of running injuries. Also, that good running technique may be more important than shoe selection, and that individual runner variation trumps any general rules.
While acknowledging the attractiveness of the evolutionary born-to-run barefoot hypothesis, Noakes et al believe “the current promotion of barefoot running is based on oversimplified, poorly understood, equivocal, and, in some cases, absent research.”
They conclude: “There remain more questions than answers at present. Future research may elucidate some of these answers, but current advice, based on tenuous justifications and associations between biomechanical factors and injury do not by themselves constitute a compelling argument for barefoot running.
I can’t believe I found your blog! The only place anywhere on the internet to address sesamoiditis and running…
My husband has been struggling with a fractured sesamoid for months and just recently an MRI revealed avascular necrosis. He is incredibly sad. Is this the end to his running? Do you have any suggestions? So far, all the foot specialists we’ve seen lack any specific perspectives for runners… My husband does have very flat feet and I’m assuming they are partially responsible for the problem, but it was blunt trauma to the area during a race that seemed to have started it all. I sorely miss my running partner 🙁
Is there hope?
great post, very informative. I wonder why the opposite specialists of this sector do not understand
this. You should proceed your writing. I’m sure, you have a
great readers’ base already!
Link exchange is nothing else however it is only placing the other person’s blog link on your page
at proper place and other person will also do similar in favor of you.