Plantar Fasciitis: Why it’s becoming an epidemic in our society.
I figured I would kick of May’s blog posts with a bang and discuss one of the most common pathologies we treat in podiatry. Heel pain. More specifically plantar fasciitis. Each day I encounter numerous patients suffering from this in either a chronic or acute form. Why is it so prevalent in our society? I’ll give it my best to try to explain why it is so common.
To begin with, we live in a society that thinks we need “good shoes” for our feet because we need to “support” our arches. How do we define “good shoes” and “support”. It’s obviously very subjective, but the ultimate answer is our feet aren’t looking for shoes or support. Remember the days of being a kid and running outside barefoot? Still today as you watch any young child they can’t wait to kick their shoes off and run barefoot. I bet most of you reading this article who are on your feet all day can not wait to get home and take off your shoes. Why? Our feet were meant to work without shoes. Consider, it’s the only part of our body that we “support” or wear something on that we feel is “needed” to function. But do we need shoes? If you examine the history of shoe gear, you will see that it has evolved over time from being an item that simply protected the soles of our feet from the environment, to a rigid device with a heel and tons of cushion and support. We really have no scientific reason for this. In fact, a lot of it has come at the the discretion of the shoe industry and fashion world. How many men really want to be in a stiff soled dress shoe with a 3/4 inch block for a heel? Probably zero. Even the ladies who LOVE their high heel shoes can’t wait to take them off come the end of the night. I’m sure you’ve seen, or even experienced, someone taking off their high heels at a wedding because their feet were killing them. I had a friend reach out to me last week about having his plantar fasciitis “flare up” again because he is standing in the OR all day in dress shoes. He wanted to solve the problem by getting some “inserts”. Inserts may help. The key word is “may”. Scientific studies do show improvement to some of those wearing the inserts, but we still don’t know why or what it is actually doing. The support or change in position they are providing can be achieved naturally by strengthening the foot and improving our postural musculature to reduce abnormal pressure to our feet and arches. The means for prescribing and fitting orthotics, although taught to follow a systematic implementation, often becomes very a haphazardness approach differing from one practitioner to the next. Even the lab that is performing the minute measurements and creating the device often produce something different then what was intended by the clinician due to the human error involved given the difficulty level measuring the joint’s angles and range of motion. What advice should I give my friend? I told him I would certainly get him into orthotics if he wants, but for starters, “you need to get out of those dress shoes!!!”. Strengthen the feet a bit by walking naturally without supportive shoes and see what happens. It’s not that he needs an arch support, he needs to learn how to stand and walk again. Maybe a consultation with a 5 year old child would help!!
Continuing on with the discussion of “do we need shoes?”. I would think so. But not shoes as most of our society tends to think of them. Let’s try to simplify this:
Men’s and Women’s dress shoes: These are status and image needs. Our society has created this. The shoe is in no way protecting our feet, nor is it providing support. It’s basically creating injury. If you weren’t expected to wear them, most likely you wouldn’t.
Industrial Shoegear: Many occupations require steel toe boots, or stiff soled boots for protecting the feet from hard objects etc. This is probably needed to protect the foot from becoming damaged due to trauma. The real challenge lies in allowing the foot to function naturally, yet protecting it from the environment.
Athletic Shoes: This can be an extremely controversial topic. What is best for the foot during the challenge of an athletic event? Most athletes have developed some sort of strength for their feet throughout life so the shoe at this point it is necessary to allow them to participate at a higher level. This of course does not account for all athletes and there are still situations where many athletes, even runners, develop plantar fasciitis.
Everyday shoes: That’s sort of a misnomer. In the US, shoes are a fashion statement. Period. I’m sure many of you at one point have heard someone say, “Those are cool shoes! Where did you get those?”. Point being – are they needed?
So where am I going with all of this? Our society, in one way or another, has influenced our selection of what we place on our feet for more reasons other then to protect them from the environment. Over time this leads to standing, walking, running, and functioning in a manner that is not normal for the body. Our body responds by compensating, not using the postural muscles to keep us standing and eventually the joints become stressed given the unnatural movement and lack of musculature control. Eventually the muscles become so fatigued in the foot that overuse injuries occur leading to the catch all term plantar fasciitis. What do most individuals do at this point? They go out and look for a “good shoe” and the circular process continues.
It would be very interesting to see what would happen in our society if would could crack the code on shoe gear and move from what is expected to be on our feet to what should be on out feet. We’ve seen a complete industry shake up in the running shoe world as a market of minimalist shoes have come into existence. Some may argue that they have existed for years known as racing flats. This is very true, however, they were not worn by the masses. Running is one of the only sports where you train in a shoe that is completely different from that of which you compete in. Does it make sense to wear a supportive shoe for the majority of your training which weakens your foot to then go and compete in a racing flat which is going to make your foot work harder to stabilize itself and absorb the impact at foot strike? Podiatrist Kevin Kirby, an advocator of using orthotics for running injuries both for treatment and prevention, advocates running barefoot as a training tool to increase strength to the foot. He also has called minimalist shoes a fad advocating runners to adhere to the unproven paradigm of stability and motion control shoes that are prescribed according to foot type. This approach does not make sense in accordance to the sport specific model of training. It’s difficult for me to understand how we can advocate so many different approaches to the foot for running (orthotics, stability control shoes, racing flats, and barefoot) when they are all very different. Why would you want to immobilize the foot and not strengthen it during training by using orthotics and motion control shoes. It would be like telling a baseball pitcher to wear a sling all week while practicing to protect the arm, then on game day go out and through as hard as you can. I’m not sure that’s being done in the major leagues.
In conclusion, plantar fasciitis is a lot like many of the illnesses our society continues to see by lack of prevention. Using orthotics and rigid shoes to treat it, is not much different then masking high blood pressure by taking medication instead of exercise and diet. You may be able to control it, but the causes are still there. Hopefully we will see a change in the paradigm used to treat this condition which will end the frustration of many patients who are not responding to the current model. Studies are being conducted by myself as well as others in the field that have been showing promise to the new proposed treatment. Paradigm changes take time and obviously one of this magnitude will take even longer.
Related Posts
-
Minimalist shoes: A Significant Advance or Injuries Waiting to Happen. Point-counterpoint.
No Comments | Oct 15, 2013 -
Reebok ZPrint Running Shoe Review
6 Comments | Mar 13, 2016 -
SKORA Fit Running Shoe Review.
No Comments | Oct 23, 2014 -
How Runners Can Improve Foot Strength – Competitor.com
1 Comment | Sep 4, 2015
About The Author
Dr. Nick Campitelli
Dr. Campitelli is a podiatrist in Akron, OH specializing in foot and ankle surgery with an interest and enthusiasm for running as well as helping runners with injuries. For the past several years he has been treating running injuries in patients by fixing their form and transitioning them to minimalist shoes. Having treated runners with all types of injuries through conservative measures with orthotics and shoe gear changes to reconstructive foot and ankle surgery, Dr. Campitelli has brought what works best and is most current to his practice as well as the Akron and Cleveland running communities.
Reminds that the frequent use of cortisone for this disorder contributes to the severity and recurrence we so frequently treat.
Agree
how do you think society’s increased obesity and overweightness affects rates of foot problems? off topic, are barefoot shoes ok for hallux limitus/rigidus?
Great post, Dr. C. If only more healthcare providers realized the foot-weakening effects of conventional footwear and inserts, then PF would probably not be the epidemic it is. Thanks!
Interesting post. I wish there were a clearer scientific consensus on this issue. My wife has PF and I am on the fence as to whether she should continue to work on it by wearing VFFs regularly (she has a pair that she exercises in) or whether she should get inserts for her work shoes, or both.
Frustrating!
The line about masking the problem struck a chord with me – I never really thought of it that way, that by using orthotics to help relieve the pain, we are really just bypassing the real underlying problems.
I use custom orthotics to treat my plantar fasciitis – and they do work (at a high cost) but you are correct that when you stop using them, the pain comes back, so they are not really treating my mechanical issues.
Great article – thanks. It’s always good to hear about PF from a professional.
Robyn can you show us one peer reviewed study, research or any systematic reviews that support your assertion that your statement “foot-weakening effects of conventional footwear and inserts” actually “weaken” feet? What do you base your statement on excepting the website that you have a financial interest in by selling minimalist/barefoot items and a relationship with it’s adherents?
Robyn can you show us one peer reviewed study, research or any systematic reviews that support your assertion that your statement “foot-weakening effects of conventional footwear and inserts” actually “weaken” feet? What do you base your statement on excepting the website that you have a financial interest in by selling minimalist/barefoot items and a relationship with it’s adherents?
In response to David Wedmeyer’s comment, what I refer to as formal footwear in the sandal which has structures emanating from the sole that wrap up and over the dorsum of the foot and in some cases about the ankle in an indiscriminate manner, predated current knowledge of functional anatomy by about 10,000 years. What peer reviewed science can you or anyone cite that supports this footwear format which became the defacto standard that prevails today? The best thing about conventional footwear is that it is based on a great business model that necessitates professional foot care and which primed the market for a perceived need to support the foot. Had such support been necessary we would not be here today to debate this issue.
David the question still hasn’t been answered: “can you show us one peer reviewed study, research or any systematic reviews that support your assertion that your statement “foot-weakening effects of conventional footwear and inserts” actually “weaken” feet?”
Are you a clinician David, I’d really like to understand your background that leads you to make these statements. I can tell you that plantar fasciitis is not caused by proper, supportive footwear and foot orthoses, it is frequently relieved by them though.. I often am referred patients with chronic PF and the success rate of appropriate footwear is not anecdotal, barefoot.minimalism is. Not once has a physician recommended barefoot.minimalism as a treatment and the great majority of plantar fasciitis cases resolve unceremonously with a combination of proven therapies. Barefoot/minimalism is not one of them.
Biomechanically kinematic function, range of motion etc are not greatly altered kinematically while the kinetics are. Basically an AFO brace, rigid boot, cast etc will alter and possible atrophy muscle, due to limitited motion,diminished activity etc. but a shoe (excepting high tops and boots) and in-shoe foot orthoses will not cause muscle weakness as you assert. Look at any in-shoe gait analysis system and tell me that i am incorrect?
Do you wear eyeglasses, a seat belt, do you brush your teeth, wear clothing? You see where i am going. Do all of these devices “weaken” the body? By that token aren’t eyeglasses a “crutch”? They affect the physical properties of light but not the structure and the same it is with shoes and anyone rational person would agree the benefit outweighs any negative in either case.
David (and Robyn) please read Dr. Doug Richie’s excellent analysis of the subject and if your position despite the research that he presents is unchanged then please present credible evidence to the contrary (not opinion).
http://www.podiatrytoday.com/blogged/do-foot-orthoses-cause-muscle-weakness
Thank you for this article, as it reminds us of great runners who needed no shoes to excel. Think of the great long distance runners from Africa and athletes like Zola Budd.
How about all the stingy offices where we have to follow the dress code and wear clunky dress shoes? How do we get around that?
Thanks Dr. Nick Campitelli for this article. useful and informative post.
Shoes can cause plantar fasciitis, but shoes can help you treat plantar fasciitis too. Make sure your shoe fit your feet. I think we should wear shoes which gives the largest area for weight distribution for both prevention and cure from plantar fasciitis.
Lovely article. Especially the masking part. A lot of us don’t realize that our shoes and insoles are only supporting the weak parts of our feet. I wrote an article on strengthening the arches of the foot: https://www.thesewisefeet.com/how-to-fix-flat-feet/
Would love to know what you think about building the intrinsic muscles of the foot doc! Especially for those who have to be in constricting supportive footwear for 14 hours a day.